How to Buy Your First Rental Property

I bought doors before I ever bought a home.

Duplexes. Fourplexes. Renovate, move, renovate, move. I didn’t buy a house to live in until I had my son at 34. By then, real estate had already made me a millionaire. That happened in 1999, and it started with very small properties.

So when people ask me how to buy your first rental property, I don’t start with countertops and paint colors. I start with the three rules I’ve used my entire career:

  1. Buy for cash flow, not a pretty house.
  2. Live where you want, invest where it makes sense.
  3. Use other people’s money and a field partner.

Let’s walk through each one with real numbers. Then I’ll show you the piece almost everyone skips, the one that protects you when something goes wrong.

Pick Your Lane Before You Pick a Property

Most first properties come in through wholesaling, fix-and-flip, or a small single-family rental. Those are the typical beginning stages. They aren’t the only doors in.

I’ve had clients with very little money get in through Airbnb management. They ran the bookings, built the marketing, and got paid 20% for property management plus the repairs. Some of them used that seat to negotiate an equity position in the property itself.

Then there’s commercial. Here’s the line: four units or less is residential. Five units or more is commercial. Commercial comes in two forms. You buy apartments in A, B, or C neighborhoods, or you buy true commercial property, where businesses lease space in buildings you own.

Mobile home parks belong on the starter list, too, especially if you need an affordable way in. With more experience, look at RV parks and storage units, particularly along interstate highways. Since COVID, plenty of people have chosen that lifestyle, and they’re still living it.

So decide where you want to be. The real question is what kind of money you have and how you plan to do it.

“Pick your lane before you pick your property.”

Buy for Cash Flow, Not a Pretty House

Ladies, I’m talking to you on this one. This is a rental house. It is not your home.

You don’t need all the extra accouterments. Your tenant doesn’t pay you for your taste. Your tenant pays you for a clean, safe, well-managed place to live.

Here’s a basic bread-and-butter single-family deal:

  • Purchase price: $45,000
  • Down payment: $4,500
  • Repairs: $1,500
  • Rent: $695 a month
  • Mortgage, taxes, insurance, and management: $495 a month
  • Cash flow: $200 a month

That’s $2,400 a year on roughly $6,000 in. You get your money back in about two and a half years, and everything after that is mailbox money.

In The Millionaire Maker’s Guide to Wealth Cycle Investing, I tell the story of Jed Stone. He had $3,000 in his Wealth Account. A friend put in the other $3,000. They bought one of these exact houses through an LLC and split the $200 a month. Then, with the right strategist, they also deducted depreciation. Residential real estate depreciates over 27.5 years, and on the $36,000 house portion, that came to $1,309 a year between them.

Jed didn’t stop at one. Within two years, he raised enough money for 15 more homes.

But for your first property, go small. Pick something manageable. Pick something that won’t take the majority of your net worth. A first-time investor needs restraint. This deal is your education, and the profit is a bonus.

Before you fall in love with anything, run the numbers. One of my clients built a tool at AskRealEstateCoach.com. You plug in any address, and it tells you pass or fail. Load photos and it estimates whether your repair budget lands in range for that zip code. It even flags whether a struggling property has a management problem, a marketing problem, a location problem, or a structural problem.

“This is a rental house. It is not your home.”

Live Where You Want, Invest Where It Makes Sense

I’ve lived in some amazing places. Downtown New Orleans. Manhattan Beach. Lake Tahoe.

None of those are where I buy B and C apartments.

For that strategy, I go to the Midwest. Oklahoma is my millionaire market. It’s where I’ve done the most transactions of my career. In Oklahoma City and Norman, we bought entire blocks, renovated them, and changed whole areas of town. I’m headed back there this week to sit down with the brokers and the teams who helped me hit that first million.

I’ve also invested in Kansas, Ohio, and Indianapolis. I go as far west as Idaho, which still has some really good buys. I did a lot of work in Arkansas back when Bentonville was coming up. Missouri and Mississippi have great finds, too.

Here’s the contrast. Most people buy where they live because it feels comfortable. Wealthy investors buy where the math works and let a team handle the miles.

When you’re choosing a market, answer four questions:

  1. What’s the strategy, and what kind of real estate fits it?
  2. Who do you know in that market?
  3. Can you find a field partner there?
  4. Can you bring capital into that market?

You can open Zillow tonight, pull properties in a Kansas or Missouri market, and start running deals.

“Most people buy where they live. Wealthy investors buy where the math works.”

Make Your Field Partner an Owner, Not a Vendor

A field partner is someone who lives in the market where you invest. I made up the term years ago, and it changed how I bought real estate.

Here’s how most people do it. I bring the money. They bring the deal. They collect a commission and go home.

Here’s what I did instead. I made them a full equity partner in an LLC, and the LLC bought the real estate. Now I don’t have to fly out to every property. My property management lives right there in the field, run by someone who treats the asset like their own, because it is.

The splits vary. Sometimes it’s 50/50. Often the field partner takes 50% to 60%, and the money side takes 40%. You negotiate based on who brings what.

“Make your field partner an owner, and they’ll protect the asset like it’s theirs. Because it is.”

Use Other People’s Money and Other People’s Credit

The most available money in the country sits in uninvested or poorly invested 401(k) plans, trillions of dollars.

With a self-directed IRA, that money can fund a construction loan or a hard money loan. It can buy pure equity alongside other investors. If you structure it as a note, expect to pay around 12% on average, sometimes 10%.

Now think about credit. If you stay in small residential properties, someone has to qualify for the loan. I call it OPC: other people’s credit. A partner with strong credit is worth as much as a partner with cash.

In commercial, larger apartments qualify for non-recourse financing. The bank lends against the property itself. If the property goes into default, the bank takes the property back and resells it through its own channels.

After almost 30 years of coaching, I see the same pattern. Clients start with small residential and fix-and-flips. If they get the math, they move to commercial fast. That move takes capital, so start building those money relationships now.

“A partner with strong credit is worth as much as a partner with cash.”

Put It in an Operating Agreement, Not a Handshake

This is the piece almost everyone skips.

Put the property in an LLC. Insure it. Structure it right and get it taxed right. Then write an operating agreement that actually fits real estate.

In parts of Mississippi, Arkansas, Georgia, and Texas, tenants still walk up and pay in cash. I have clients with mobile home parks full of cash payers. If that’s your market, you need controls. Who handles the cash? Where do checks land? I’ve seen property managers and field partners set up a post office box that nobody else can see into.

So build in transparency on the bank accounts. Set spending limits. Then have the hard conversations. If one of you passes away, does the property get re-evaluated and sold, or does the cash flow keep going to your family? What happens in a divorce? Does each partner have a right to correct before anyone gets bought out?

Death and divorce are the two topics most partners never discuss. Discuss them before you close.

“Make sure it’s not a handshake agreement.”

Start Today

Here’s your week:

  1. Pick your lane. Single-family rental, small multifamily, mobile home park, or a management seat.
  2. Choose one market where the math works, and pull ten listings.
  3. Run the bread-and-butter math on every one: price, down payment, repairs, rent, expenses, cash flow.
  4. Find a field partner. Call three people who live and work in that market.
  5. Check your retirement accounts. Find out whether they can move into a self-directed IRA.

Want to know what’s been holding your money back? Take my financial personality quiz.

If you want help with your operating agreement or your first deal, call my office at 775-588-9200 and ask for a one-on-one conversation.

Your first rental doesn’t need to be pretty. It needs to pay you.

Go to AskLoral.com. Ask a question, make a request.

Click here to watch the YouTube video.

Share this :
What's the #1
Obstacle Holding
You Back from
Ultimate Wealth?

Our Flagship Wealth-Building Programs